Home

This is my family’s go-to pizza place in Grove City, and we’re really happy that they built this location on the South side of Grove… read moreThis is my family’s go-to pizza place in Grove City, and we’re really happy that they built this location on the South side of Grove City.
The staff is always friendly and the restaurant is always clean. It’s always on-time, no matter if I order pickup or delivery. Ultimately this Flyers was a godsend during the pandemic when everything else was closed and you needed something a little special for the family.
A few pro tips:
-The old world pepperoni is a little thicker and a little spicy. It’s the best pepperoni in my opinion.
-The sausage is actual finely crumbled Italian sausage, not those giant weird chunks that you’d get from a national chain.
-Order a “well done” bake for a more traditional (non national chain) pizza shop bake. Everything ends up a little more crispy, from the toppings to the crust.
-Don’t be afraid to order the chicken or other traditionally fried foods. Flyers actually uses deep fryers, as opposed to putting everything through the pizza oven. Things come crispy as you’d want them to be.
-Try their homemade chips. They’re fried in the store, you get a lot for you money, and most of all theyre amazing. read less – 10/16/2021

Super good Stromboli. The bomber was an awesome pizza. Highly recommend getting you pizza here. Not a fan of the “Columbus cut” but if you’re… read moreSuper good Stromboli. The bomber was an awesome pizza. Highly recommend getting you pizza here. Not a fan of the “Columbus cut” but if you’re reading this you are probably already familiar. So it makes no difference. read less – 10/13/2021

GRACYN IS THE BEST EMPLOYEE EVER. she’s so nice and is cute too. go flyers i love u – 10/12/2021

Great staff, always seem happy to be there. Food is just as good! – 10/12/2021

Just ordered my 1st pizza from here while in town. I’m a truck driver and I really prefer to not eat truck stop pizza. So… read moreJust ordered my 1st pizza from here while in town. I’m a truck driver and I really prefer to not eat truck stop pizza. So flyers thin crust meatlovers was it and they did not dissatisfy. Amazing pizza. They threw in a few cookies for me and sweet baby Jesus their bussing read less – 10/10/2021

We ate inside. The service was great and of course our pizza was on point! – 10/10/2021

This Is A Great Pizza With A Great Staff. Warm Employees, That Dedicate Theirselves To High Quality Service…A1…. – 10/09/2021

Great pizza ! Food come out hot quick and good service ! – 10/06/2021

Best pizza in Ohio. Its our go to pizza place. The price is high but the taste is worth it. – 10/04/2021

Ordered flyers for the first time at home..always had it work when the bosses have pizza Thursday..but its usually cold by the time I get… read moreOrdered flyers for the first time at home..always had it work when the bosses have pizza Thursday..but its usually cold by the time I get some. So..I’m happy to say that flyers is my top 5 for Columbus pizzeria..I was very impressed with the service, the quality, the texture, and the taste..just awesome! read less – 9/25/2021

Awesome pizza… very clean!
The staff was excellent! – 9/22/2021

Best pizza and sub I’ve ever had, fast and friendly service. I’d highly recommend checking this place out if you’re in the Columbus area – 9/21/2021

There was a mishap with my order this evening and it accidentally didn’t get sent through from my order taker (who was very friendly). The… read moreThere was a mishap with my order this evening and it accidentally didn’t get sent through from my order taker (who was very friendly). The manager was quick to remedy the situation and immediately offered to make the pizzas within 10 minutes at half price. Half price Flyers pizza is SO worth a 10 minute wait! Not only was it fast, but this was hands down the best pizza we’ve had in years. I mean it. Years. Made to perfection! My husband was like Bill Murray eating dinner in What About Bob; nonstop commenting how much he was in love. read less – 9/20/2021

My favorite pizza place. The food is excellent and the staff are always friendly. The company is very generous in their support of… read moreMy favorite pizza place. The food is excellent and the staff are always friendly. The company is very generous in their support of both Lions Clubs in Grove City and we greatly appreciate it!!! read less – 9/18/2021

Love Flyers the pizza is always good sandwiches as well. Delivery is usually timely within an hour. – 9/18/2021

Mozzarella sticks, mac n cheese bites, and chicken tenders were god awful. Thin crust pepperoni pizza was good but prefer donatos. After a few… read moreMozzarella sticks, mac n cheese bites, and chicken tenders were god awful. Thin crust pepperoni pizza was good but prefer donatos. After a few years we had this place again several times and things were a lot better read less – 9/17/2021

My family and I are long time customers, because we absolutely love their pizza. Though the pizza is always great, the one we got today… read moreMy family and I are long time customers, because we absolutely love their pizza. Though the pizza is always great, the one we got today seemed especially awesome. So I thought I should leave a review as thanks. If you like a thicker thin-style pizza and enjoy trying local pizza places over the national chains, then I highly recommend checking out Flyers! By the way, they also have a thick style crust, which we tried recently. I am not usually a fan of thick crust pizza, but I was incredibly impressed with how good their dough is. read less – 9/11/2021

I’ve ordered many a pie from here. I’ve tried all the crusts, all of the specialty pizzas, a few of the non-pizzas. The quality is… read moreI’ve ordered many a pie from here. I’ve tried all the crusts, all of the specialty pizzas, a few of the non-pizzas. The quality is constantly good, and honestly after trying a lot of the other locals, it’s still my #1 choice. read less – 9/09/2021

This location is the best! 5-star service every visit! You’re treated like family. – 9/08/2021

As chain pizza goes, Flyers is one of the better ones. Pizza bombs are a yummy snack, and work sometimes gets us pizza for lunch…. read moreAs chain pizza goes, Flyers is one of the better ones. Pizza bombs are a yummy snack, and work sometimes gets us pizza for lunch. It’s always good. read less – 8/28/2021

Seriously the best pizza. Nice and thin but not crispy which is my favorite. Nicest people that work there too. Super polite. – 8/21/2021

My son and I had the Nightmare sub and my wife had grilled chicken sub and DIL had club sub. Sandwiches very good and homemade… read moreMy son and I had the Nightmare sub and my wife had grilled chicken sub and DIL had club sub. Sandwiches very good and homemade chips were awesome. I ask for salt for my sub and was told they didn’t have any ?? and dining room floor felt greasy. Not good for seniors, hence the loss of a star. I would come back again. read less – 8/16/2021

My son and I had the Nightmare sub and my wife had grilled chicken sub and DIL had club sub. Sandwiches very good and homemade… read moreMy son and I had the Nightmare sub and my wife had grilled chicken sub and DIL had club sub. Sandwiches very good and homemade chips were awesome. I ask for salt for my sub and was told they didn’t have any ?? and dining room floor felt greasy. Not good for seniors, hence the loss of a star. I would come back again. read less – 8/16/2021

Not sure if Flyers is the best pizza in Columbus since it’s the only one I’ve had while coming through, but it stacks up… read moreNot sure if Flyers is the best pizza in Columbus since it’s the only one I’ve had while coming through, but it stacks up with any here in Cincinnati. Now that me, my friend Dan and the server now know what their pizza bombs are that’ll be ordered next trip in. My wife is really picky about pizza, and she loved what I brought home.
That says pretty much everything! read less – 8/16/2021

Love this shop. I’m a regular customer. The Cobb salad is incredible. Best salad in Columbus and excellent value for the money…. read moreLove this shop. I’m a regular customer. The Cobb salad is incredible. Best salad in Columbus and excellent value for the money. The grilled chicken on it is the best chicken anywhere. Excellent, high-quality, fresh ingredients every time. Love their chicken tenders. Always hot and crispy. Fast delivery. Wish they had a bigger dessert selection. Their funnel fries don’t work well with delivery; they’re always soggy and limp. I think they’re more of an in-restaurant dessert. Cookies are meh. Cheesecake would be a nice addition. Orders are ALWAYS correct for me. Staff is always polite and efficient. Keep up the good work. read less – 8/15/2021

I haven’t eaten at a Flyer’s in 10+ years, still tasty and super super clean. Staff is awesome and positive and friendly like I remember…. read moreI haven’t eaten at a Flyer’s in 10+ years, still tasty and super super clean. Staff is awesome and positive and friendly like I remember. Restrooms super clean too!!! Thank you!!! read less – 8/12/2021

Best pizza and subs ever I ordered there all the time and you have to try the three cheese bread it’s amazing – 8/05/2021

Grew up with flyers and hadn’t had it since I was little. Grabbed a pizza and wings for some friends and I and it was… read moreGrew up with flyers and hadn’t had it since I was little. Grabbed a pizza and wings for some friends and I and it was as good as I remembered. The pizza is certainly something I will order again, the wings were average but little complaints there. Happy this opened up so close read less – 7/31/2021

Great experience for dining. I didnt realize until after ordering that I can go next door, get a beer and order my pizza from the… read moreGreat experience for dining. I didnt realize until after ordering that I can go next door, get a beer and order my pizza from the Pub. Nice set up if you want Pizza and beer one stop shop. Customer service was excellent at both places. If you are in the area give it a try. (Also the coney/sandwich place on other side has good food also. read less – 7/28/2021

The service was over the top! I wish I would have gotten the girl’s name. Pizza was great! Loved the funnel fries! – 7/24/2021

We really liked this place. The staff were so friendly and really went above and beyond. The decor was very neat and the restaurant was… read moreWe really liked this place. The staff were so friendly and really went above and beyond. The decor was very neat and the restaurant was clean. The pizza was pretty decent too! read less – 7/23/2021

Pizza good, sauce a little sweet, I always ask for light sauce. I miss the whole wheat crust pizza they used to have . They… read morePizza good, sauce a little sweet, I always ask for light sauce. I miss the whole wheat crust pizza they used to have . They aren’t stingy with the toppings either read less – 7/16/2021

Have been eating Flyers in West Jefferson for the past 35 years and will continue to stop in whenever the opportunity arrises.
Great food that is… read moreHave been eating Flyers in West Jefferson for the past 35 years and will continue to stop in whenever the opportunity arrises.
Great food that is always hot and fresh.
Definitely recommended! read less – 7/07/2021

I love it everything be on point and every time I’m up here I get a pizza and wings and take it back to Alabama… read moreI love it everything be on point and every time I’m up here I get a pizza and wings and take it back to Alabama best pizza I ever had keep up the good work and customer service read less – 7/06/2021

Clicked the wrong stars earlier! Definitely 5 stars for the pizza buffet at lunch. They keep it well stocked, comes with a drink, and has… read moreClicked the wrong stars earlier! Definitely 5 stars for the pizza buffet at lunch. They keep it well stocked, comes with a drink, and has desserts! Will be back. read less – 7/05/2021

Amazing pizza and even more amazing staff! Cool environment too! We were in town from Cincinnati to go to the Columbus Zoo. We decided to… read moreAmazing pizza and even more amazing staff! Cool environment too! We were in town from Cincinnati to go to the Columbus Zoo. We decided to cap off our Columbus visit at Flyers and it was the perfect ending to a beautiful day! Our kids (9 and 6) loved the pizza also! The 2 year old has been hit and miss with pizza so we ordered him some plain, boneless wings and he crushed them! I am ready to visit again! 😁 read less – 7/03/2021

Lunch buffet is open M, W, F and always has more than just pizza. I have never been disappointed with any of the menu items. – 7/02/2021

Flyers is fantastic. Pizza industry is competitive but flyers figured it out. Whole menu is good. Very fresh vegetables. – 6/30/2021