What Our
Customers Say
- Anonymous U.
I love this place. People are always nice and food is always good. I can always count on flyers for a good meal and great service. I had the fried mushrooms and they were so good I had to write this review! – 10/16/2026read moreread lessModern g.The buffet was actually good especially for the price. Add spaghetti chicken wings hamburgers in brown gravy, mashed potatoes, corn, chicken nuggets, salad made the ride on my little scooter 20 minutes there 20 minutes back 40 minute ride worth it LOL – 9/28/2026read moreread lessMegan R.Reliable pizza. Ordered delivery. I’m usually not a huge fan of Flyers (my husband is), but the pizza we got this time was delicious! We ordered the Quattro (just cheese) and added pepperoni, which they put under the cheese. It was the perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni. Will be doing this same order moving forward! – 9/22/2026read moreread less - Richard B.Another great lunch today! I have (on purpose) tried the Lunch Sub meal, then the Lunch Calzone meal and today a Lunch Meatza Pizza meal. Each time I have added or subtracted something just to see what would happen. The food was as advertised, hot and ready when I was there. Couldn’t get much better, but I am having a hard time picking a favorite! I think I’ll start over and do it again. The new ordering system is great! – 9/21/2026read moreread lessRichard B.Been stopping by the Flyers Pizza Hilliard occasionally since they opened. Got a take-out today with a complicated lunch Stromboli and sides order, all using the new ordering app. Everything was hot, fresh, fast, accurate and as I wanted it. I might have found a new lunch favorite! My compliments to the in-house staff and to the new ordering app. Every restaurant should be so lucky to have such a good ordering system, thank you Flyers. – 9/14/2026read moreread lessDani M.The customer service was top notch! The lady at the counter was very friendly and welcoming! I placed my order for 6pm but arrived at least 36-40 minutes early and the manager was very accommodating! I received a piping hot fresh pizza and fresh salad under 15 minutes! The pizza was so delicious that it was the highlight of my day! – 9/02/2026read moreread less
- sugar t.Other flyers power went out and we came here instead. First time at this one and I could just sense the strength in this staff. They were going as fast as they can, keeping the restaurant clean even with people filling up the lobby and phone calls nonstop. They were efficient and doing a great job. I truly appreciate the staff for their hard work, its not their fault the wait was just slightly longer than usual. Keep it up! – 8/22/2026read moreread lessJustin C.Everyone needs to experience their mystery pizza once!
I ordered joeys choice mystery pizza. But Zach was entrusted by Joey to make my mystery pizza… oh boi Zach came up with the best combo.
Flat bread pizza with
DICED onion, green pepper, and ham with crumble sausage.
Emphasis on the dice because I’ve never had a pizza loaded with toppings and be enjoyable to eat.
I also ordered some cheese garlic bread and I put the pizza with the bread to make a AWSOME sub sandwich. Honestly this mystery pizza night became one of the best pizzas I’ve ever ate in my life. Having no idea what pizza I was gettin; made the anticipation so much better.
Zach did awesome he knows pizza – 7/25/2026read moreread lessGriffin P.Ordered at 10:15 when they close at 11pm and I felt TERRIBLE. Lydia who took the phone call was so nice and reassuring that it’s fine and it wasn’t to late. I show up to pick up my food and Alex the closing manager was so kind and professional also reassuring about how it was totally fine. It’s rare to come across any service industry business now that have great employees who make customers feel valued. Highly recommend this place. Once again shoutout Lydia and the manager Alex. – 7/25/2026read moreread less - Theodore L.Absolutely outstanding! The pizza was delivered hot, fresh, and cooked to perfection. Every bite was packed with flavor, and you could really tell they use quality ingredients. On top of that, the customer service was phenomenal—friendly, professional, and genuinely cared about making sure everything was perfect. It’s not often you find both amazing food and exceptional service in one place, but they absolutely nailed it. I’ll definitely be ordering again and highly recommend them to anyone looking for a fantastic pizza experience! – 7/24/2026read moreread lessMisty H.My first time at Flyers. It was really good. I got a gluten free pizza and the crust was delicious. – 7/14/2026read moreread lessCorey C.Honestly one of the best values around with the buffet. We always come in with a large group and we are always all satisfied with the food and you really can’t beat it for 12 bucks. Really awesome place. – 7/14/2026read moreread less
- R N.A new favorite pizza place
I was skeptical but decided to try them out
Orders 2 pizzas and picked them up
Pleasantly surprised as the pizza was actually good, crust was perfect and toppings were good
Overall price was more than I’d like but was pleased with the pizza nonetheless
Differently worth a try – 7/14/2026read moreread lessDavid H.I was waiting for my Quattro pizza with half pepperoni when I was told it had accidentally been made without any pepperoni. It was an honest mistake, and I was fine with it, but they insisted on making me the correct pizza while letting me keep the first one. While I waited, they offered me a fountain drink and great conversation. I left with two pizzas and a reminder that great customer service still exists. Not to mention, the food is always top tier. So, another reason to love this place. Thank you! – 7/14/2026read moreread lesslisa m.Another fantastic meal from Flyers! 🍕 They never disappoint. We had a medium pizza loaded with pepperoni, sausage, onions, and banana peppers, and I ordered a small pizza with no sauce, topped with bacon, tomatoes, onions, and pineapple. Every bite was fresh, hot, and absolutely delicious! The crust was perfect, the toppings were generous, and everything was cooked just right. Flyers has never let us down, and that’s why we keep coming back. Highly recommend if you’re looking for consistently great pizza! – 7/11/2026read moreread less - Angela L.First time customers!! The food and service were both top notch! Garlic bread was soft on the inside and crusty on the outside and Meatza pizza was fabulously dressed!! Drinks were refilled timely and server was very knowledgeable and friendly. Will definitely be back!!! – 6/27/2026read moreread lessA G.I’m a pretty regular patron and generally have my order delivered. I don’t know how they can get it to me so fast after my online order. It’s like they knew what I wanted before I knew it myself! Always delicious, fresh, and handled with care. One day soon maybe I’ll get to the store and order in person. Just for a treat! – 6/23/2026read moreread lessRichard M.The buffet was excellent at a good price. The only thing that might help would be a dessert style pizza. – 6/22/2026read moreread less
- Mike F.Food was great there sausage and pepperoni pizza was very tasty and the Italian sub also tasty no complaints 5 stars – 6/22/2026read moreread lessATNFlyers Pizza on Roberts Rd in Hilliard is my go-to and it never lets me down. Every single visit is consistent and that consistency is exactly what keeps me coming back.
This visit I had the BBQ chicken pizza and it was everything. The perfect balance of smoky BBQ sauce, tender chicken, and melted cheese on a Flyers crust that you just can’t beat. If you haven’t tried the BBQ chicken pizza here you’re missing out — it’s one of those orders you don’t even have to think twice about.
What makes Flyers stand out in Columbus is the reliability. You always know what you’re getting and it always delivers. No surprises, no disappointments — just good pizza done right every time. That’s rare and it’s why Flyers has been a Columbus staple for as long as it has.
Whether you’re feeding the family, grabbing a quick dinner, or ordering for a group, Flyers Pizza on Roberts Rd in Hilliard is the move. Don’t overthink it — just order the BBQ chicken pizza and thank yourself later.
A Columbus classic for a reason. Never going wrong with Flyers. – 6/09/2026read moreread lessAmadouFlyers Pizza on Roberts Rd in Hilliard is my go-to and it never lets me down. Every single visit is consistent and that consistency is exactly what keeps me coming back.
This visit I had the BBQ chicken pizza and it was everything. The perfect balance of smoky BBQ sauce, tender chicken, and melted cheese on a Flyers crust that you just can’t beat. If you haven’t tried the BBQ chicken pizza here you’re missing out — it’s one of those orders you don’t even have to think twice about.
What makes Flyers stand out in Columbus is the reliability. You always know what you’re getting and it always delivers. No surprises, no disappointments — just good pizza done right every time. That’s rare and it’s why Flyers has been a Columbus staple for as long as it has.
Whether you’re feeding the family, grabbing a quick dinner, or ordering for a group, Flyers Pizza on Roberts Rd in Hilliard is the move. Don’t overthink it — just order the BBQ chicken pizza and thank yourself later.
A Columbus classic for a reason. Never going wrong with Flyers. – 6/09/2026read moreread less - Nina A.Just ordered med pizza, with pepperoni, Mushroom, extra cheese,onion…Pizza was delicious& bread sticks.. I talked to the manager, Nick. He was very kind and considerate, and made sure my order was correct & delivered quickly….😁 I want to shout out to the whole team they did a great job… Thanks Nina – 6/06/2026read moreread lessTeri R.We always enjoy Flyers. We really like to order the Mystery Pizza. Tonight was really good; pepperoni, green pepper, red onion, and pineapple.
Does pineapple belong on pizza?
YES, it absolutely does! – 6/06/2026read moreread lessNancy K.Delicious pizza and we tried the Stromboli for the first time! It was delicious as well. Pick up was fast and easy. Employees are friendly and efficient! Highly recommend. – 5/30/2026read moreread less - Nicholette B.They always get my order right and it’s always ready on time. Maybe occasionally it takes a little longer but it’s worth the wait. Delicious food and friendly staff. Very rare in food service these days – 5/28/2026read moreread lessShawn H.Our go-to pizza place! Thin bread-like dough with high quality toppings. A little pricey, but worth it to us. – 5/09/2026read moreread lessAlex G.Food is consistently fantastic and probably some of the best pizza around. The only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 is the new app. The previous app was much better and easier to use. The new interface feels like a downgrade, and not being able to track when your order is ready is really frustrating. Hope they improve the app because the food itself is still great. – 5/08/2026read moreread less
- Barbara M.This is the best Flyers location. The pizza us always delicious, love the sweeter sauce.
The spring salad has the freshest lettuce.
My favorite place for 🍕. – 5/01/2026read moreread lessMary A.They offer a wide variety so there is something for everyone including salads. Been using Flyers as my go to pizza shop for years and they never disappoint. I highly recommend them. – 4/29/2026read moreread lessNancy B.I love flyers ..can’t get if often cause it’s pricey.
Service was great..got delivery order almost 10 mins early. I actually got the extra cheese on my pizza and egg in my salad. Outstanding job!!! – 4/19/2026read moreread less - FallenPolarizedOrdered take out, waiting for well over 30 mins after they told me it would be done. I wasn’t upset about it cause I understand they are busy. The girl at the window (orange hair and glasses) immediately offered me credits and apologized and gave me and my girlfriend cookies and a refund for the order. She was way too kind and took care of us. They should give her a raise cause anytime I’ve had her at the window she’s talkative and kind. I very much appreciated the great service. – 4/15/2026read moreread lessMelissa N.I decided to use my birthday reward tonight and also try the stromboli. Omg it was so good, everything was hot and fresh. I appreciate everyone there who made this a great experience. I’ll be back for another stromboli soon. Thanks. – 4/13/2026read moreread lessRyan F.The sauce was too sweet for my liking, but I give this a 4/5 because the cheese and toppings were very good, The service was quick courteous and generous. If only I liked the sauce more. If you like sweeter sauce, then this may be a 5/5 for you. Got a half cheese half pepperoni medium pizza, which was enough for one adult and two kids under 10. – 4/10/2026read moreread less
- Erik S.Getting in and out of the parking lot area was my only complaint. Very tight quarters. The service here was fantastic. I had a large order and all the pizzas were still warm when I got to my destination. The employee asked me if I needed any plates and napkins, and he helped me take the pizzas out to my car. Excellent store. – 4/09/2026read moreread lessJuan C.Tried it for a pizza trail and will definitely be back. The bomber was solid and the traditional pep was really good. I’m not usually a thin crust fan but that might have changed my mind! – 3/30/2026read moreread lessDon M.Ok. Who doesn’t love a pick up window at a pizza parlor!? Serving carry out, as well as the bar next door, you are in for a treat! Thin crust with great toppings! The Bomber is the works of pizza! We also love the creamy garlic sauce Pizza with chopped tomatoes, sliced mushrooms, and grilled diced chicken. So flavorful that we always get a large for 2 days of leftovers! Plus if you use the app or call in they help you remember your favorites!
Enjoy! – 3/24/2026read moreread less - Sarah M.I always get my pizza here, but I got one Friday and I tell you!! It was the best looking and so tasteful pizza I’ve EVER had!!! The crust was perfectly made with the outer crust so crunchy and the right amount of sauce and the cheese… omg it’s the Best!! And the pepperoni just the right amount of spice and crunchy on the edges!!! I’m a customer for LIFE and I HIGHLY RECOMMEND this FLYERS on Robert rd!!! It’s always on my mind now!!! Thank you FLYERS PIZZA!!!😊😋 AND THEIR PRICES ARE THE BEST!!! – 3/23/2026read moreread lessKaren F.I love the pizza, but I also love the variety of the menu. Subs, appetizers, salads, I’ve had it all and its all good. The bomber is my favorite as far as pizzas, also im a thick crust gal and my husband is a thin crust guy, I like that their thin crust still has a dough texture and not cracker or cardboard. I’ve never eaten at the restaurant but they seem to have a big dining area. – 3/17/2026read moreread lessKevin A.Hands down some of the best pizza i’ve had yet. Great staff, clean restaurant. – 3/04/2026read moreread less
- Sarah H.Great food and great deals. I love the pick up window, it’s convenient when you have kids in the car. They have great subs, pizza, and wings. – 2/26/2026read moreread lessDavid T.The fresh made chips that come with the sub were SO good. Sub was perfect. And I enjoyed the pizza. I ordered The Bomber and I was pleased with the toppings combo. Especially the heavy-handedness with the green peppers. Drove to try this place because of the deal on the Clipp app. Thankful for the introduction! – 2/22/2026read moreread lessSarah K.I had such a great experience at your flyers tonight! The order was ready before expected, and to be honest I placed the order just a couple minutes before close and the staff were so friendly and kind anyways. The pizza was cooked perfectly as well! 10/10 (as usual), but appreciated you all a little extra tonight! – 2/16/2026read moreread less
- Becki B.We love having family meetings at Flyers Pizza! 3 cheese garlic bread, pretzel bites with cheese, Saratoga chips, and of course the pizza… you can’t go wrong!
Another great meal at Flyers. Service was great! Pizza, pretzel bites, and Saratoga chip…the best!
Excellent thin crust pizza and pretzel bites with cheese. Saratoga chips a nice bonus! – 2/15/2026read moreread lessKelsey G.The blonde lady who I spoke with was very nice and personable. The pizza was so good. It was recommended by one of my daughters, and I thought it would just be “ok”, because that’s what I think when anyone tells me about their favorite pizza spot…but it was great! We got the thin crust pizza with pepperoni and sausage. – 2/14/2026read moreread lessSamantha P.Exceptional pizza, strombolis, and appetizers every time! My kids are very picky and they called to make sure my one pizza order was accurate and not an error. Thank you always! Worth the drive. – 2/05/2026read moreread less - Jessica E.We visit this location very often and the food is always so great! We recently ordered a pizza did not quite meet our standards, but the employees were quick to correct it for us and they still served us with a smile! Our go-to pizza place for sure! – 2/03/2026read moreread lessMimou K.You are the best, you have the most delicious pizza I’ve ever eat – 1/27/2026read moreread lessJohnathan B.Place was very nice! Atmosphere was awesome, however the pizza was extremely greasy. Pad it with a paper towel if your not to busy, or don’t if you’re alright with REALLY greasy pizza – 1/27/2026read moreread less
- Sandra C.Usually order for delivery.
The food is always great and I love the sauce they use for their pizza!! It’s the best in town as far as I’m concerned!! I even called to see if I could buy it in bulk!!
Give them a try, I think you’ll be glad you did!!!!😋😉😃 – 1/22/2026read moreread lessHaley C.This is my absolute favorite pizza place. Would even go as far to say my Disney World. I’ve eaten flyers pizza since I was a youngling and 18 years later I can still say it’s the best, I don’t think anything compares to this great luxury of pie. Honestly deserves its own Michelin stars. – 1/20/2026read moreread lessJustinSome of my favorite pizza in Columbus. Still use their own delivery drivers and not a third party app. The quality is always spot on. Delivery tracker always says 45 minutes, never takes that long. – 1/18/2026read moreread less - Jay C.Love this place. I ordered a pizza from a another location and thought it was sent to this Galloway location. Turns out it was at Grove City location and instead of having me drive there they went ahead and make my order there and canceled the other one. Great Service. Great people. One of the best in town. – 1/17/2026read moreread lessRayThis flyers is the best around. Thank goodness I work nearby or I’d have to make a longer drive to get the right pizza. The food is always amazing, the workers are always super friendly and helpful, and the atmosphere is always great too – 1/15/2026read moreread lessDr. C.We have always enjoyed Flyers pizza and its whole menu. For every pizza or other food items we have tried here, we have never been disappointed. – 1/04/2026read moreread less
- layha 3.I haven’t been to Flyers in years. My son and I went in to order food. The lady was so helpful with the menu and explaining the items on the menu asking with the different ways it could be mixed up. She offered us drinks while we waited for the food. I truly appreciate their customer service. It was definitely the best experience. The place was very clean, very festive because it was also Christmas time. Everyone was super nice and really helpful. We even ended up with a free pizza. The food was so good. The food was definitely fresh, very savory and yes of course I will be back to dine in. – 12/31/2025read moreread lessTIna C.Quality food and service. Never had an issue in the 15 yrs I’ve been a customer. Moved away and came back and looked forward to ordering from here. 10/10 recommend everything is good here, I mean EVERYTHING! – 12/30/2025read moreread lessSusan R.I’ve loved this place since I met my husband. He worked here when it was called Tonni’s and there was a donut shop on the same strip 😊 – 12/30/2025read moreread less
- Edward(Can anything be done to improve your experience?) Nada. The ability to make the time to do 2X well done, accurately, in, and of, itself, says it all. That, plus the weight in box rocks! – 12/24/2025read moreread lesslaura p.Absolutely love Flyers! Order it at least once a week! The best food, nothing is ever wrong! Lady at window every single time I pick up is awesome! So nice and polite, I think she’s a manager! Thank you for everything! We love Flyers! – 12/13/2025read moreread lessShirley G.Philly steak.. the best!
Chef salad always very fresh and tasty. The free chips, when eating in-house, is a big plus! – 12/12/2025read moreread less - Suzanne D.We have been ordering from Flyers for the past 12 years and our food always arrives in a timely manner and it’s always steaming hot. We will continue to support this business and employees. The employees are always very nice. We have only had a couple times where something was forgotten but they will make it right and deliver whatever was forgotten and sometimes throw a free pizza on our account. Thanks for always being a reliable source of dinner for us when we don’t feel up to cooking. – 12/06/2025read moreread lessCoco T.I’ve gotten a pizza here so many times in the past 2 years because its both convenient and quick but also because its absolutely some of the best pizza I’ve had in Columbus.
I can always count on Flyers to be quick, cooked properly, with fresh toppings and perfectly seasoned sauce. Whether you choose pickup or delivery (they have their own delivery drivers too which is super convenient when compared to ordering from a 3rd party service and only 5$ additional on your order instead of a bunch of extra fees.
I ordered a pizza for delivery at 4:53pm and it was at my door by 5:15! You really cant ask for a better pizza or delivery option. Plus the workers are always kind, friendly and prompt.
Dont skip them! – 11/25/2025read moreread lessAnh H.The store in Hilliard is my favorite. I almost order their pizza every week. They have best service in both delivery and customer support. I highly recommend the place! – 11/15/2025read moreread less - Low K.Seriously, one of the greatest pizza places I’ve ever had, consistently for over 4 years now.
The crew is always focused on your food, the drivers deliver order with a smile. The food has always been top notch.
I mean, realistically 98-99% of my Za orders have been perfecto, the 2%, let’s be honest, I have made some weird topping combinations…lol
I’m a pizza snob, but Flyer’s on Roberts Rd has had my service, multiple times a month, multiple times, because I enjoy their consistency and attention to quality.
I’ve never received a burnt pizza from here, I’ve never received a soggy pizza from here, I’ve ordered all kinds of pizzas. I’ve gotta be near 100+ pizza’s at this point, that’s why I’m taking the time to write this.
Anyways,
Dear Owner, or Manager that reads this:
I appreciate you for allowing your team in this specific location to perform so well, they will be great at whatever they do, keep them making pizzas, plz!
I’ve worked just about every position in a restaurant in the past, including management, and I’ve read these reviews in the office, but I’ve never felt a place deserved a review like this.
Take care of these people, they care about your investment.
Thank you for the crispy peps over the years 😉
The pizza looked absolutely perfect
and it got completely eaten
I apologize for no photo.
11/10/2025 – 11/11/2025read moreread lessAaron F.My family and I eat here quite often. We have never had a bad experience. We choose their gluten free options due to food allergies and have never had an allergic reaction. Pizza always tastes great too. The staff is very friendly and helpful. We will continue to go back and rest assured knowing we will have a great experience. – 10/31/2025read moreread lessLisa R.We have ordered from the Galloway Flyers for many, many years. There food 99.9% of the time is amazing. The other .1% if there has ever been an issue, they always make it right immediately. – 10/28/2025read moreread less - Bonita M.We must have forgotten how good Flyers was because we haven’t purchased in a while. We will definitely be ordering again! We love the sweeter sauce and the pepperoni seemed to have some spice to them which was great!! Fast delivery and hot when arrived. Delivery driver was pleasant! 10/10 overall. – 10/25/2025read moreread lessNic W.Can’t start to describe the little things that make a big difference in this crew they have at this location.
People make the difference!
Food is amazing as always and my daughters favorite ! Which is what she requested for her 4th birthday.
Once again thank you flyers staff !! – 10/23/2025read moreread lessWildflower S.Got the meatza pizza and it was amazing! They bring out hot potato chips as an app. NICK was amazing and so friendly and helpful! Thanks for having us! -Kristen from Wyoming. – 10/22/2025read moreread less - Shirley S.All I have to say is…go get your flyers fix from this location. The lady up front took my order made sure I knew what sizes there were and made sure to insure I had all my side sauces and double checked my sub was light baked. Im a very picky person and she went above and beyond to insure I had great food and a wonderful experience. To your cook in the back. NICE JOB BEST ORDER IVE HAD IN A LONG TIME. BOTH LADIES NEED RAISES AND UPPER MANAGEMENT YOU BETTER KNOW WHAT YOU GOT ON YOUR TEAM. – 10/20/2025read moreread lessNorman G.Keep up the good work! Tonight’s Dilluxe pizza was just how I like it. Very delicious, very spicy!
I’d recommend this whenever someone asks me about good pizza. – 10/18/2025read moreread lessJ W.The pizza was real good and the service was great we had a large order and they had everything correct – 9/26/2025read moreread less - Paul B.Once again. I can’t say it enough. Flyers Pizza Galloway always knocks it out if the park. Order was perfectly prepared. Hot upon arrival. Delicious as usual. The individual that brings the order is always courteous. I never consider anyone else when it comes to ordering pizza. Flyers Galloway is definitely the spot. – 9/20/2025read moreread lessMike F.I have to say that the last 3 or 4 times we have ordered at the Blacklick location have been awesome. I mean really great. I saw Larry Winslow in there one night so I am not surprised! Happy this place is close to my house! This day and age it is tough and this location is doing incredible! Thank you! You are appreciated! – 9/18/2025read moreread lessDeborah C.We have always gotten take out and utilized the pick up window. Very convenient. Staff at the pick up window always very pleasant. Pizza always excellent. Stromboli very good too . – 9/13/2025read moreread less
Flyer’s Pizza – Your Favorite Pizza in Central Ohio for Over 49 Years! We Proudly serve the communities of Hilliard, Grove City, Groveport, Blacklick, Pickerington, Powell, Galloway, and West Jefferson. Whether you’re craving delicious specialty pizzas, subs, salads, or mouth-watering starters, we’ve got something for everyone.
- Locally Owned & Operated: Flyers Pizza is committed to delivering the best pizza in the outer Columbus areas.
- Wide Menu Selection:
- Our Famous Specialty Pizzas: The Bomber, Old World Pepperoni, Ultimate BBQ Chicken, The Hawaiian & more.
- Oven Baked Subs: The Nightmare, Italian, Meatball, Philly Steak & more.
- Fresh Salads: The Chef, Cobb, Spring & more.
- Savory Starters: Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, Pretzel Bites, Cheddar Bacon Fries & more.
- Proudly Serving Pepsi products.
- Convenient Ordering: Use our app, order online, or simply give us a call to enjoy the best pizza and fast delivery in your area.
- Pick-up Windows: Most of our Locations offer this easy form of grab & go for you to enjoy hot, fresh pizza near you.